Good baseball video games are tough to come by. Even the best developers have fallen victim to junky control mechanics or wonky baseball physics. Like many other sports games, once a developer finds a control scheme that works, it is best to just stick with it and tweak it as required with each new version. The difficult part is finding solid control mechanics to use. Fortunately, MLB 10: The Show has this in the bag. With a few other baseball options on the market now, is this truly the best one? read on…
GRAPHICS (10/10)
Although EA Sports has trademarked its slogan “It’s in the game”, it should really consider leasing that motto to Sony for this game. It is amazing the amount of detail that made it into this game. It is amazing to see Derek Jeter come to the plate and do his little shimmy before getting in his batting stance or seeing an outfielder dust off his uniform after diving for a ball. There are just counteless minor details that baseball fans will just eat up.
The graphics themselves are pretty spectacular also. The players actually look like the players and not some crazy CGI rendered images of players. Often times player models will look good when up close or at the plate, but show that same player waiting on first base and he suddenly looks mildly deformed. This is not the case with MLB 10 where all the players look realistic all the time. The stadiums are all perfect replicas of their real life counterparts. If you’re playing at Fenway the Green Monster is brought to life with lush detail. Everthing from the billboards to the scoreboards to the players just screams authenticity in this game.
GAMEPLAY (10/10)
As pretty as the game looks, this is what it all really comes down to. Fortunately, the game more than delivers in thsi department. The game utilizes the same tried and true pitching mechanics that require you to push the proper face button to select your type of pitch, then use X to aim the pitch and determine how hard it will be thrown. Batting is also fairly simple as you use “x” for a contact swing or square for a power swing. I have never once used the quare button while batting and I haven’t had any problems connecting with X. Regardless, these control interfaces are by far the best ever created in a baseball game. Other games (such as MLB 2k10) use different control schemes and they wind up falling flat due to the high margin of error involved with the inputs.
The only gripe I had is with the fielding and how players dive for balls. For example, when you are using the shortstop and you are chasing a liner that your guy could easily pick up, sometimes the game never initiates the animation for the player to scoop the ball up, resulting in your player being on top of the ball and it rolling between his legs into the outfield. This is especially frustrating when you have a double play perfectly set up only to be robbed by some shoddy hit detection which prevented your player from picking up the ball. While this is not a gamebreaker, it is very frustrating. There were so many times when I would have pitched a perfect inning only to be robbed by a bobbled ball that results in a 2 run RBI. Maybe this is omething that can be fixed with a patch, but for now its just the way things are.
SOUND (7/10)
The sound of the games is actually pretty good. The crowd roars loudly whenever something exciting happens. The ump’s voice is distinguishable as he calls out strikes. The crack of the bat echoes through your speakers when a batter makes contact. All of he sound effects are great and really give off that stadium vibe.
The one thing that brings down the audio portion is the horrendous commentary. For the most part, the commentators are fairly decent. There are a lot of times when they will add their 2 cents at the worst possible times. If you ever strike out, you will most likely get an earful about it from the commentators as if they were the batting coaches. Its bad enough to strike out but then to hear the commentator ripping you about it just makes things so much worse. there were seriously times when I wanted to just walk up to their booth and punch them, they get that irritating.
ONLINE (7/10)
The online games I played were pretty lag free, but not completely. For a game like this, one second of lag can mean the difference between winning and losing. I can’t count the number of times I would’ve had a strike out only to fall victim to lag resulting in my pitch being slow and getting crushed out of the park. it is just too difficult to hit or pitch when you are fighting lag at the same time. I’m sure people with really good internet connections can probably play this game online without any problems but when I played I always fell victim to lag.
OVERALL (9/10)
This game is a must have for nay baseball fan out there. Unfortunately it is only available on PS3. This is one of the few PS3 exclusive titles that make 360 owners green with envy. When compared to the baseball offerings on other systems, MLB 10 smashes those hands down. The learning curve for this game is fairly steep, but once you start to get it down it is one of the most rewarding gaming experiences around. MLB10: The Show is by far the best console baseball game I have ever played, perhaps even the best sports game I have played.