WARNING!! THIS REVIEW CONTAINS SPOILERS!!!!
Let me start by saying that I loved the first Transformers movie. In all honesty, if I were to make a list of pros and cons about the movie, I think the list would be pretty even. But if you look at the weight of each item, the positive far outweighs the negative. Optimus Prime producing a sword from his hand and decapitating Bonecrusher under the freeway definitely makes up for John Turturro in his Sector 7 underwear getting peed on by Bumblebee. Likewise, Jazz’s annoying ebonics and breakdancing are more than made up for by seeing his body ripped in half by Megatron’s bare hands while perched atop a skyscraper. The list goes on and on, but the bottom line is that every annoyance in the first film is easily washed away by the sheer badassery of other elements of the film.
Unfortunately, after watching T:ROF, the negative outweighs the positive. It reminded me of a fighter who is being paid to throw a fight. They do just enough to look like they’re trying to win, while the whole time they are setting themselves up to lose. One of the gripes from the first film was that there weren’t enough robot battles and that the ones that were featured were almost too clunky and awkward to clearly determine who was who. Director Michael Bay really does a great job of not only throwing in more incredible action scenes, but also in cleaning them up so that they are easier to follow. The action scenes are just awesome and Bay has really upped the brutality level in all of the fights. Watching the Transformers battle it out is what audiences pay to see, and in that respect the flick more than delivers.
Sadly, almost everything between these battles is excruciatingly painful to watch. I can accept the Transformers movie having minimal character development and plot holes big enough to drive Optimus Prime through. However, what kills me is the fact that Bay felt the need to include humor that seemed like it was written by the writers of ‘Meet the Spartans’ and ‘Disaster Movie.’ Robots farting, robot balls dangling, Old Robot with a cane, and a robot leg humping a human are all featured in this film. Are these the elements this incredible franchise is reduced to? Apparently so.
As far as characters, Bay introduces so many meaningless additional characters while at the same time ruining existing characters. There is a Decepticon who can transform into a hot college coed. Her transformation amounts to nothing more than a metallic looking ‘Species’ rip off and her inclusion in the movie is highly unnecessary. Then there are Sam’s new sidekicks and protectors who have earned the nickname ‘Car Car Binks’ from various other reviews due to their irritating nature and the stereotype they personify. These twins speak in full ebonics, have gold teeth, and are dumb as a box of rocks. While I wasn’t anywhere near as irritated by them as a lot of other people (I actually found them kind of funny in a ‘I can’t beileve I’m laughing at something this stupid’ kind of way) I did feel that their inclusion was also very unnecessary.
Then there are the existing characters. In this film, the almighty Megatron is reduced to, for lack of a better term, a little bitch. In the first film, he was an unstoppable monster who nearly killed Optimus Prime. Here, he is reduced to the role of subservient errand boy. Then there is Soundwave, who is nothing more than a glorified talking sattelite in space. Don’t even get me started on Bay’s treatment of Devastator or Jetfire. One thing is clear, the threat of the Decepticons is considerably less menacing than in the first film.
There are numerous other problems that I had with the film, but these are the more major ones that I can think of right now. Is it a good movie? yes, but by no means is it great. There are quite a few elements that make it worth watching. The previously mentioned action scenes are top notch. While the physicality of the Transformers seems to have lost a bit of freshness from the first movie, it is still a blast to watch them throw down on screen. Sam’s interaction with his parents is still pretty damn funny. Surprisingly, John Turturro is less annoying in this film and is actually one of the funnier, more entertaining characters. Believe it or not, Megan Fox actually got a bit hotter in this film also.
So while the movie didn’t quite live up to the hype and promise of the original, it is still very entertaining despite all of its flaws. I’ll be watching it again since i have to take my son to go see it. Who knows, maybe my opinion of the film will change after another look. As it stands in my mind right now, it’s a good and entertaining flick that is definitely worth watching at least once.
CRS, I was writing a review yesterday, and I think you touched on every aspect of the film that disappointed me. No reason to write a second review because you hit everything on the dot.
Megan Fox is still smoking hot in this film. The dialogue among the transformers was just horrible! Who writes that stuff!!
guess i’ll wait for it to hit the 2 dolla theatre.
yeah, save a few bucks ray. Its definitely not worth paying full admission for. I’d probably pay for it again however to watch it in an IMAX theater. Since my first experience watching Kung Fu Panda via IMAX, I’ve always wanted to go back! haha
It was a bit dissapointing. I’m hoping that when I have to watch it again, the action scenes will be enough to get me through it. Then again there are some horrible and completely unnecessary action sequences too!
Big ups to Megan Fox for convincing Paramount Studios and Michael Bay to spend half of the movie’s $200 million on lip gloss! Talk about money well spent!
I could live with the action sequences. They were top notch and exciting. The story and dialogue were absolute garbage though. The decepticon’s were not menacing at all.
They should have left prime dead, at least for this film. I thought it would have brought more to the table for a third. Killing off THE FALLEN that easily didn’t help either.
I think a big part of it is that Bay didn’t want to make a third film. However he could’ve easily streamlined the plot of this one into two more solid movies, leaving Optimus dead or even introducing a new leader like in the old animated film.
Part of me is still hoping the film will grow on me a little more when I watch it again.
I dont think it will make a difference if I watch it again or not. For action buffs, this film is going to be fun, but for those who need some sort of cohesive story, this movie is trash.
I’ll watch it in IMAX and hope that the experience adds to the positives!
yay! it’s finally here! :D
I was disappointed too. Although the dialogue was a lot funnier in this one, I thought the inuendo was overkill.
And I was a little distracted with my (5-year-old) son constantly asking me to explain some of the scenes–the dogs humping each other, the little snitch bot humping Mikaela’s leg, and the “scrotum” part.
The decepticons were so weak in this one. (I was actually afraid for them.)
The “lost city” of Petra? That was way too cliche for the primes to have hidden the matrix there. I was half-expecting Indiana Jones to pop up and reveal other hidden treasures.
It was fun but longwinded with dialogue. I was hoping they’d feature more autobots or decepticons in close-ups.
The sexual undertones kind of took the childhood memories away.
(Fox was hella hot, but I prefer the subtlety of her character in the first movie.)
I accidentally slept in the middle of the movie. Interestingly, the fighting scenes got me snoozing. Too much of one thing can lead to many things.
They need to just kill all the people in T:RotF and let the film be about, I don’t know, Transformers! All the robot action scenes were awesome, but can they the rest of the Autobots do more than just drive/run around killing things?
this movie was fuggin dumb! but i loved the explosions and i love that the robots have balls now. oh stop crying you transformers purists babies.
stop crying foul about thems two robots with bad grammatics. they are meant for the dumb high school crowd. you know the kind that can’t spell or write simple sentences and will be graduating from high school by social promotions.
and how bout that megan fox? ai adai, saying bad shiit about michael bay. are you kidding me? gurl, don’t talk crap about the man that made you a star. granted michael bay’s movies are equivalent to a middle school education but still.